Comparison
Kinds Security vs Adaptive Security: 2026 comparison
Adaptive Security is the stronger choice for teams that need custom deepfake video of named executives, because its Custom AI Deepfake Personas feature turns a photo, a voice sample and a script into a downloadable video in minutes. Kinds Security is the broader choice for US regulated mid-market teams, especially when teams need simulations branded to the apps each person actually uses, an AI security advisor every employee can ask, and audit exports for CMMC, FINRA and cyber insurance.
Every Adaptive Security figure on this page was read from Adaptive Security’s own published pages on 25 August 2026. Sources are listed at the foot of the page.
At a glance
| Criterion | Kinds Security | Adaptive Security | Bottom line |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing | $1.50 per user per month, flat, with every feature included. Billed monthly, no setup fee and no minimum; annual is available but never required. | No rate card is published. The pricing page states products are “licensed per seat, per year” and routes every buyer to a quote form. The only public dollar figure anywhere is an AWS Marketplace “Elite Package, <100 Employees” at $5,988 per 12-month contract. | The two cannot be compared like for like. Kinds Security publishes the rate you pay; Adaptive Security publishes one small-business bundle whose seat basis the listing itself does not state. |
| Trial and buying process | Self-serve signup with a 21-day trial, every feature unlocked, no demo call required. | Quote-gated. No self-serve signup exists on adaptivesecurity.com, and TrustRadius states “No free version or trial is available for Adaptive Security.” | You can evaluate Kinds Security before speaking to anyone. Evaluating Adaptive Security starts with a form. |
| Phishing simulation channels | Email only, with 850 app-branded templates. Voice phishing is practised inside the AI Voice Phishing workshop rather than sent as an unannounced call. | Email, voice, SMS and deepfake video, described as coordinated attacks across channels. Vishing uses AI-cloned voice calls impersonating executives, IT helpdesk staff or vendors; deepfake simulations are built from public OSINT. | Adaptive Security runs more channels. Kinds Security runs one channel and teaches voice attacks inside a workshop instead of calling people without warning. |
| Simulation delivery | Delivered through the Microsoft Graph and Gmail APIs. There is no SMTP sender, so there is nothing to allowlist. | Its integrations page lists “Gmail DMI” and “Outlook DMI” — direct message injection for phishing simulations. The site does not describe the transport for anything outside those two, and its own how-to posts tell admins to allowlist a platform’s sending IPs and domains and to configure SPF, DKIM and Microsoft’s Advanced Delivery policy before sending simulations, written generically rather than about its own product. | Kinds Security’s delivery is API-only and documented here. Adaptive Security offers direct injection for Gmail and Outlook; what carries a simulation outside those two is not stated anywhere on its site, and no third party has verified any of it. |
| AI and deepfake threat training | The AI Voice Phishing workshop: the learner takes a live AI voice call and hears their own voice cloned inside the lesson. Deepfake video appears as a fourteen-second “real or deepfake?” clip in the Phishing & Social Engineering workshop. There is no admin tool for generating custom deepfake video. | Custom AI Deepfake Personas: an admin supplies an image, a short audio reference clip and a script, and Adaptive returns a custom deepfake video “generated in minutes,” downloadable into training content via its frame builder or usable off-platform. | Both put synthetic media in front of learners. Only Adaptive Security generates it to order, of a named executive. |
| Compliance frameworks driving assignment and reporting | 12, each one selectable so the matching content assigns itself and a one-click audit PDF comes out the other side: HIPAA, SOC 2, PCI DSS, ISO 27001, CMMC, NIST CSF, GLBA/FTC Safeguards, FINRA, Texas DIR, LSC, cyber-insurance attestation and state Safe Harbor. | 24 on its compliance page: CCPA, CPRA, PCI DSS, HIPAA, FedRAMP, SOX, GLBA, FCPA, PIPEDA, LGPD, GDPR, UK GDPR, NIS2, AML/CFT, POPIA, POSH, PDPA, PIPL, APPI, Australian Privacy Act, SOCI, SOC 2, ISO 27001 and NYDFS. | The two numbers do not measure the same thing. Adaptive Security names 24 on a marketing page; Kinds Security’s 12 are wired into the product — pick one and the matching content assigns itself, then one click produces the audit PDF, with per-framework attestation wording and a SHA-256 hash in the footer. Five overlap; Adaptive Security’s remainder is international privacy law, and Kinds Security’s is US sector regulation. |
| Audit evidence | A one-click PDF per framework, scoped by date range, organization and an include-or-exclude toggle for inactive learners, carrying a SHA-256 integrity hash so an assessor can confirm the file was not edited after export. | “Every completion, score, and timestamp logged automatically. Export reports formatted for auditors by framework, by employee, by date range,” with every framework tracked individually — “audit-ready in one click.” | Both export per framework and per date range. Kinds Security adds employee-level scoping choices and a hash on the artifact itself. |
| Content library and languages | A curated set of chat-style workshops, each under seven minutes and assigned automatically, delivered in 32 languages. | “1,000+ resources,” described as interactive and fully customizable, plus an AI Content Studio that generates modules from your policies or prompts. No language count appears on the training page; the only figure found (“40+ language narration”) sits on Adaptive’s own KnowBe4 comparison page. | Adaptive Security’s catalogue is far larger and generative. Kinds Security ships a fixed short set nobody has to curate, and publishes its language count as a product spec. |
| Integrations | Microsoft 365, Google Workspace and Okta over OAuth, which is what supplies users, roles, managers and app usage. | Nine identity sources including Entra ID, GCC High, Google Workspace, Okta, Rippling, JumpCloud, OneLogin, Ping and CyberArk; fourteen HRIS connectors including Workday, ADP, SAP SuccessFactors and BambooHR; Drata and Vanta for compliance evidence; Slack and Teams for delivery. | Adaptive Security has the wider integration surface. It matters if you provision from an HRIS or push evidence into a GRC platform. |
| Product scope | One product covering awareness training, email phishing simulation, risk scoring and compliance reporting, with Clay — an AI advisor learners can ask by text or live voice call — inside the workshops. | Three products — Security Awareness Training, Email Security and AI Governance — sold individually or bundled. Email Security quarantines inbound threats by API; AI Governance monitors employee AI use in the browser and feeds it into risk scores. | Adaptive Security can consolidate awareness training and email security on one contract. Kinds Security does one job and prices it as one product. |
| Best-fit audience | US regulated SMB and mid-market teams — defense supply chain, financial advisors, healthcare, state agencies and legal aid — plus MSPs running every client tenant from one dashboard. | Enterprise security teams. Adaptive states over 1,000 security teams use the platform, naming Perplexity, Bose, PayPal, Figma, Ramp, MLB, Xerox, NHL, PGA, Vimeo and TaylorMade Golf, across finance, technology, government, healthcare, hospitality, sports and education. | — |
Where Adaptive Security is stronger
Generating custom deepfake video
Adaptive’s Custom AI Deepfake Personas feature takes an image, a short audio reference clip and a script, and returns a custom deepfake video in minutes — of a named executive, for leadership messaging or role-specific finance and HR scenarios. The video can be dropped into training through Adaptive’s frame builder or downloaded for off-platform campaigns. Kinds Security ships a fourteen-second deepfake clip as a workshop exercise, but nothing that generates one to order. If executive deepfake video is the requirement, Adaptive Security is the product that meets it.
More simulation channels in one program
Adaptive simulates across email, voice, SMS and deepfake video, and describes running them as coordinated attacks that mirror how real attackers operate. Its vishing uses AI-cloned voice to impersonate executives, helpdesk staff or vendors, and its deepfake simulations are assembled from public OSINT. Kinds Security simulates email only.
Framework breadth for international privacy law
Adaptive’s compliance page names 24 frameworks with per-framework tracking and export. Nineteen of them are ones Kinds Security does not cover, and most are privacy and data-protection regimes: GDPR, UK GDPR, CCPA, CPRA, PIPEDA, LGPD, PDPA, PIPL, APPI, POPIA and the Australian Privacy Act, alongside SOX, FCPA, AML/CFT, NYDFS, FedRAMP, NIS2, SOCI and POSH. A multinational with obligations across several of those is better served there.
Integration surface, adjacent products and scale
Nine identity sources including Microsoft GCC High, fourteen HRIS connectors including Workday, ADP and SAP SuccessFactors, and Drata and Vanta for automated compliance evidence. Adaptive also sells Email Security and AI Governance alongside the training product, has raised $146.5M, and states over 1,000 security teams use the platform, naming customers including PayPal, Figma, Bose and MLB.
Where Kinds Security is stronger
Frameworks a US regulated mid-market buyer is actually asked for
Kinds Security generates against 12 frameworks, and seven of them are ones Adaptive Security does not name: CMMC, NIST CSF, FINRA, Texas DIR, LSC, cyber-insurance attestation and state Safe Harbor. That is the defense supply chain, financial advisors, state agencies, legal aid and the insurer questionnaire an SMB has to answer at renewal. The two products overlap on only five frameworks — PCI DSS, HIPAA, GLBA, SOC 2 and ISO 27001 — so the right question is not which list is longer but which one contains your obligations.
What each framework requires, by citationAn audit PDF an assessor can verify
The compliance report is a one-click PDF per framework, scoped to a date range and an organization, with an explicit toggle for whether inactive learners are included — the question an assessor asks first. Every export carries a SHA-256 integrity hash, so the file handed to an auditor or an insurer can be checked against the one Kinds Security produced.
What a CMMC assessor asks to seeA published price and a trial you can start today
$1.50 per user per month, flat, every feature included, billed monthly with no setup fee and no minimum, and annual available but never required. The 21-day trial is self-serve and unlocks everything. Adaptive Security publishes no rate card, quotes per seat per year, and offers no trial — so the first comparable number arrives after a sales conversation.
See Kinds Security pricingAn AI advisor employees can talk to, that admins cannot read
Clay sits inside every workshop. Learners ask questions in plain language, by text or a live voice call, and get coached answers in their own language. What they ask is never visible to their own administrators — the boundary is architectural, not a setting — which is what makes people willing to admit the password they have reused for six years.
What Clay can see, and what your admins can’tIn practice
The framework lists are different, not just different lengths
Adaptive Security names 24 frameworks on its compliance page; Kinds Security generates reports against 12. Adaptive is broader on count, and only five overlap — PCI DSS, HIPAA, GLBA, SOC 2 and ISO 27001. The rest split by buyer. Adaptive’s nineteen are mostly international privacy law: GDPR, UK GDPR, CCPA, CPRA, PIPEDA, LGPD, PDPA, PIPL, APPI, POPIA and the Australian Privacy Act, plus SOX, FCPA, AML/CFT, NYDFS, FedRAMP, NIS2, SOCI and POSH. Kinds Security’s seven are US sector regulation: CMMC, NIST CSF, FINRA, Texas DIR, LSC, cyber-insurance attestation and state Safe Harbor. A multinational counting privacy obligations should read the count as Adaptive’s point. A defense subcontractor, a broker-dealer, a Texas agency or an SMB filling in an insurer’s questionnaire should read it the other way. The two counts also measure different things: Adaptive’s 24 is a list on a marketing page, and the 12 is what the Kinds Security product generates reports from.
How a simulation reaches a person
Kinds Security simulates email, and only email: 850 templates branded to the applications each person actually uses, delivered through the Microsoft Graph and Gmail APIs with no SMTP sender and nothing to allowlist. Adaptive Security runs email, voice, SMS and deepfake video, and describes coordinating them so a pretext can move between channels the way a real attacker would. Its integrations page lists direct message injection for Gmail and Outlook; what carries a simulation on the other channels it does not say. If your threat model needs someone tested somewhere other than their inbox, that is a real limit and Adaptive Security is the product that covers it.
Two different things called AI deepfake training
Adaptive Security points the technology outward: an administrator uploads a photo, a voice clip and a script, and gets back a deepfake video of a named executive to put in front of staff. Kinds Security points it inward. The Phishing & Social Engineering workshop plays a fourteen-second clip and asks the learner to call it — real, or deepfake? In the AI Voice Phishing workshop they take a live AI call and then hear their own voice cloned back to them. Both products put synthetic media in front of people. Only Adaptive Security generates it to order, of someone the learner reports to, and for a team whose executives are the pretext that is the difference that matters.
What you can learn before a sales call
Kinds Security publishes its rate — $1.50 per user per month, everything included — and lets you start a 21-day trial with every feature unlocked, without talking to anyone. Adaptive Security publishes no numbers on its pricing page; it states products are licensed per seat per year and asks for a form, and no self-serve signup exists on the site. The one published figure is an AWS Marketplace bundle for organizations under 100 employees at $5,988 per 12-month contract, and even that listing does not say whether the price is flat for the band or assumes a seat count — so no per-seat rate can honestly be derived from it. For an enterprise with a procurement process this is normal. For a 60-person firm that wants to know the price this week, it is friction.
Deeper comparisons
Each dimension has its own fact-checked write-up with the underlying documentation.
Pricing
Kinds Security charges $1.50 per user per month, flat, with every feature included and no setup fee. Billing is monthly with no minimum, annual is available but never required, and the 21-day trial is self-serve with everything unlocked.
Adaptive Security does not publish a rate card. Its pricing page states that products are “licensed per seat, per year” and directs every prospect to a form: “Our pricing varies based on your unique environment and security needs. Fill out our form to receive a custom quote.” The page describes the company as transparently priced and without multi-year enterprise negotiations, but discloses no numbers of its own.
The only dollar figure Adaptive publishes anywhere is on AWS Marketplace: an Elite Package for organizations under 100 employees at $5,988 per 12-month contract, with 24-month (save up to 10%) and 36-month (save up to 20%) terms available. That bundle covers security awareness training, compliance training, AI training modules, phishing simulation across voice and text channels, generative content tools, AI threat triage and dedicated phone, email and chat support.
That AWS listing does not state whether $5,988 is a flat package price for any organization under 100 employees or assumes a specific seat count within the band, so a per-seat rate cannot responsibly be derived from it and this page does not derive one. There is also no trial to price against: TrustRadius states “No free version or trial is available for Adaptive Security,” which matches the quote-only flow on Adaptive’s own site. The honest summary is that Kinds Security and Adaptive Security cannot be compared like for like on price without requesting a quote.
When to choose each
Choose Kinds Security when
- Your compliance obligations are US and sector-specific — CMMC, NIST CSF, FINRA, GLBA/FTC Safeguards, Texas DIR, LSC, state Safe Harbor, or the attestation your cyber insurer asks for at renewal.
- You want to see the price and run a real trial before you speak to a salesperson.
- Email is the channel you actually need to simulate, and 850 templates branded to each person’s real applications matters more than channel count.
- You need an audit artifact with a verifiable integrity hash and explicit scoping, not a dashboard export.
- Nobody on the team is a full-time security awareness administrator, and you would rather the program ran itself.
- You are an MSP running many client tenants from one dashboard.
Choose Adaptive Security when
- You need to generate custom deepfake video of named executives from a photo, a voice clip and a script.
- Your program has to simulate SMS and voice as well as email, coordinated across channels.
- Your obligations are international privacy regimes — GDPR, UK GDPR, CCPA/CPRA, PIPEDA, LGPD, PDPA, PIPL, APPI, POPIA, the Australian Privacy Act — or SOX, FCPA, NYDFS, FedRAMP, NIS2 or SOCI.
- You provision from an HRIS such as Workday, ADP or SAP SuccessFactors, or push compliance evidence into Drata or Vanta.
- You want awareness training, inbound email security and AI-governance monitoring from one vendor.
- A large, fully customizable catalogue with a generative content studio is itself the requirement.
If you are also weighing the incumbent, the same criteria are worked through against seat-band list pricing on the Kinds Security vs KnowBe4 comparison.
FAQ
Is Kinds Security better than Adaptive Security?
Neither is better in every case. Kinds Security fits US regulated SMB, mid-market and MSP teams that want a published flat price, a self-serve trial and audit exports for frameworks like CMMC, FINRA and cyber insurance. Adaptive Security fits enterprises that need deepfake video generation, SMS and voice simulation, and international privacy-framework coverage.
What is the difference between Kinds Security and Adaptive Security?
Kinds Security is one product: email phishing simulation, chat-style workshops in 32 languages and one-click audit PDFs across 12 frameworks, at $1.50 per user per month. Adaptive Security sells three products — training, email security and AI governance — simulates email, voice, SMS and deepfake video, names 24 frameworks, and quotes every price.
Which is cheaper, Kinds Security or Adaptive Security?
A like-for-like comparison is not possible. Kinds Security publishes $1.50 per user per month, billed monthly with no minimum. Adaptive Security publishes no rate card and licenses per seat per year; its only public figure is an AWS Marketplace bundle for organizations under 100 employees at $5,988 per 12-month contract, on an unstated seat basis.
Can Kinds Security replace Adaptive Security?
For an email-focused program, yes. Kinds Security covers awareness training, email phishing simulation, an AI Voice Phishing workshop, risk scoring and audit reporting across 12 frameworks at one flat price. It cannot replace Adaptive Security where the requirement is SMS simulation, generated deepfake video, or Adaptive’s email-security and AI-governance products.
Who should choose Adaptive Security instead?
Choose Adaptive Security if you need custom deepfake video of named executives, simulation coordinated across email, voice and SMS, or evidence for international privacy regimes such as GDPR, LGPD, PIPL or POPIA. It also suits teams provisioning from an HRIS such as Workday or ADP, or pushing compliance evidence into Drata or Vanta.
Sources
- Adaptive Security — Pricing“Licensed per seat, per year”, the absence of any published dollar figure, and the custom-quote form every buyer is routed to.
- AWS Marketplace — Adaptive Security Elite PackageThe only published dollar figure: “Elite Package, <100 Employees” at $5,988 per 12-month contract, the 24- and 36-month discount terms, the bundle contents and the dedicated support channels. A third-party marketplace listing, not Adaptive’s own site.
- Adaptive Security — Custom AI Deepfake PersonasThe inputs (an image, a short audio reference clip and a script), the output (a custom deepfake video generated in minutes), the frame builder, and the off-platform use cases.
- Adaptive Security — Phishing SimulationsChannel coverage across email, voice, SMS and deepfake video, the AI-cloned-voice vishing description, OSINT-built deepfakes, and “Connect via API in minutes — no rip-and-replace required.”
- Adaptive Security — ComplianceThe 24 named frameworks, per-framework individual tracking, the by-framework, by-employee, by-date-range export, and “audit-ready in one click.”
- Adaptive Security — Security Awareness TrainingThe “1,000+ resources” library figure, the AI Content Studio, and the absence of any stated language or localization count.
- Adaptive Security — IntegrationsThe identity and directory list including GCC High, the fourteen HRIS connectors, Drata and Vanta for compliance evidence, and Slack and Teams for delivery.
- Adaptive Security — HomepageThe three-product line-up, “over 1,000 security teams”, the named customers, the vertical and company-size breadth, and the TeamGuard AI Inc legal entity.
- PR Newswire — Adaptive Security raises $81M Series BThe $146.5M total raised, the December 2025 Series B investor list, and the January 2025 public launch.
- TrustRadius — Adaptive Security pricing“No free version or trial is available for Adaptive Security.” Cited for that statement only; its review sample is a single review and is not used here as sentiment.
- Kinds Security — PricingThe $1.50 per user per month rate, the 21-day self-serve trial and what the flat price includes.
Still deciding?
If your obligations are CMMC, FINRA, GLBA, Texas DIR or a cyber-insurance questionnaire, and you would rather read a price than request one, the trial is 21 days and needs no demo call. If you need to generate deepfake video of your own executives, or to simulate SMS, Adaptive Security is the honest answer and this page has said so.