Comparison
Kinds Security vs Proofpoint: 2026 comparison
Proofpoint is the stronger choice for enterprises already running Proofpoint’s email security, because ZenGuide can auto-enroll Very Attacked People and clone real attacks their staff received into simulations. Kinds Security is the broader choice for teams buying awareness training on its own, especially when teams need simulations branded to the apps each person actually uses, an AI security advisor every employee can ask, and delivery through the Graph and Gmail APIs with nothing to allowlist.
Every Proofpoint figure on this page was read from Proofpoint’s own published pages on 25 August 2026. Sources are listed at the foot of the page.
At a glance
| Criterion | Kinds Security | Proofpoint | Bottom line |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing | $1.50 per user per month, flat, with every feature included. Billed monthly, no multi-year term, no advertised user minimum. | No list price is published. Every product and platform page ends in “Request a demo” or “Contact Us”. Resellers such as CDW and SHI list Standard and Enterprise SKUs by seat band, but their pages require a quote or an account login and show no price either. | A like-for-like price comparison is not possible from published information. Kinds Security publishes its rate; Proofpoint’s has to be asked for. |
| Where simulation content comes from | A library of roughly 850 app-branded email templates, assigned automatically. Phishing simulations are email only. | The AI ThreatFlip workflow clones a real phishing attack, removes its harmful elements and sensitive data, and generates a simulation from it. Users identified as Very Attacked People, high-risk clickers or people exposed to active threats can be enrolled in training automatically — both listed in the 2026 ZenGuide brief as benefits of integration with Proofpoint’s Collaboration Security platform. | If you already run Proofpoint on the mail path, simulations can be built from attacks your own workforce received. A standalone ZenGuide customer does not get that pipeline, and no training-only vendor can offer it. |
| Simulation delivery | Delivered through the Microsoft Graph and Gmail APIs rather than SMTP, so there is nothing to allowlist and no firewall exception to request. | Proofpoint’s managed-service brief states it will provide documents to safelist IP addresses for your email servers and to conduct spam-filter testing, and that exceptions may also need to be created in firewall or security appliances. Independent admin knowledge bases publish current Proofpoint allowlisting guides. | API delivery removes the allowlisting step. SMTP-style delivery behaves the same way in front of any mail provider, but the mail path has to be opened for it first. |
| Who runs the program | Assignments run without a campaign builder once the mailbox connection is in place. | The base product gives an administrator a campaign builder — Adaptive Pathways and Adaptive User Grouping, driven by logic-based rules the administrator defines. A Proofpoint expert becomes the hands-on administrator only under the separately sold managed tier, now branded Applied Services for ZenGuide; the commercial managed brief scopes that offering to customers with up to 2,500 users. | Proofpoint sells the managed tier precisely because the base product expects a customer-side administrator. Kinds Security assumes there isn’t one. |
| Employee reporting and coaching | Clay, an AI advisor available to every learner inside a workshop by text or live voice call, in the learner’s own language. | PhishAlarm, an email-client add-in that lets people report a suspicious message in one click; the current ZenGuide brief describes a Report Suspicious button across email and mobile devices. | Different jobs. PhishAlarm collects reports from employees; Clay answers questions from them while they train. |
| Content library and languages | A curated set of chat-style workshops, each under seven minutes and assigned automatically and delivered in 32 languages, including a dedicated AI Voice Phishing workshop where the learner takes a live AI call and hears their own voice cloned. | A large catalogue including named regulatory topics such as GDPR, HIPAA and PCI DSS. The live product and multinational-support pages describe global language support and WCAG-based accessibility without stating a current language count; older Proofpoint documents give different figures by vintage. | Proofpoint has the far larger catalogue. Kinds Security ships a small fixed set nobody has to curate. |
| Compliance reporting | A one-click, audit-ready PDF per framework across 12 frameworks — including HIPAA, SOC 2, PCI DSS, ISO 27001, CMMC, NIST CSF, GLBA/FTC Safeguards and FINRA — scoped by date range and organization, each carrying a SHA-256 integrity hash. | Reporting identifies Very Attacked People and top clickers; the Enterprise-tier brief marks the deeper attack-index and business-privilege insights as requiring Proofpoint Threat Protection. | Proofpoint’s richest reporting depends on owning its email security. Kinds Security’s audit artifact is in the base price and stands on its own. |
| Directory and identity | Connected over OAuth to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace — the same connection that delivers the simulations. | SCIM-based End-User Sync with any identity provider, named as Azure Active Directory, Okta and Ping, plus SAML single sign-on through Microsoft Entra ID with just-in-time provisioning. | Both sync from the directory. Proofpoint does it as a separate SCIM integration; Kinds Security reuses the mailbox connection it already needs. |
| Hosting and data handling | Hosting, subprocessors and data handling are published at the Kinds Security trust center. | Multi-tenant Amazon Web Services environments across three geographic regions, AES-256 at rest, TLS in transit, an annual SOC 2 Type II covering availability, confidentiality and security, and documented retention periods — 30 days for suspicious-email submissions, 18 months for analysis results. | Proofpoint publishes an unusually specific security and retention page, which shortens an enterprise security review. |
| Buying model | Self-serve signup with a 21-day trial and no demo call required. The rate is on the pricing page. | Sales-assisted throughout. No self-serve trial-to-purchase path is stated on any Proofpoint page, and the product is also sold through the reseller channel. | — |
| Best-fit audience | SMB and mid-market teams buying awareness training on its own, and MSPs running many tenants from one dashboard. | Enterprises, especially those already running Proofpoint’s email security. The commercial managed-service tier is scoped to organizations of up to 2,500 users. | — |
Where Proofpoint is stronger
Simulations cloned from attacks your own staff received
The 2026 ZenGuide brief describes an AI ThreatFlip workflow that clones a real threat, removes its harmful elements and sensitive data, and generates a realistic simulation from it — and lists it as a benefit of integration with Proofpoint’s Collaboration Security platform. This is the one thing no training-only vendor can match, Kinds Security included, because it needs your mail path and your training program to be the same vendor.
Automatic enrollment of the people actually being targeted
Users identified as Very Attacked People, high-risk clickers, or those exposed to active malware and credential threats can be enrolled into targeted training automatically — but the same brief gates that on integration with Collaboration Security, and the Enterprise-tier brief marks the deeper attack-index insights as requiring Proofpoint Threat Protection. Proofpoint’s own blog describes this as tying its email security product’s data to the awareness-training product, which is what it is: a cross-product integration, not a standalone feature.
A managed tier where Proofpoint runs the program for you
Applied Services for ZenGuide puts Proofpoint program practitioners on planning and execution; the older commercial managed brief is blunter, saying a Proofpoint expert will be the hands-on administrator of the phishing-simulation tool, for customers with up to 2,500 users. If you want the program outsourced to the vendor rather than automated away, that option is on the price list — as a separate paid tier.
A published security and retention posture
Proofpoint documents that ZenGuide runs on multi-tenant AWS environments in three geographic regions, with AES-256 at rest, TLS in transit, an annual SOC 2 Type II covering availability, confidentiality and security, alignment to NIST 800-53 and ISO 27001, and specific retention windows. Enterprise security reviews move faster when that page already exists.
Where Kinds Security is stronger
A price you can read before you talk to anyone
Kinds Security charges $1.50 per user per month, flat, with every feature included, billed monthly with no multi-year term and no advertised user minimum. Proofpoint publishes no price for ZenGuide anywhere on its site, and its resellers show none without a quote or a login. Budgeting for Kinds Security is arithmetic; budgeting for Proofpoint starts with a sales conversation.
See Kinds Security pricingNothing to allowlist before the first simulation
Simulations are delivered through the Microsoft Graph and Gmail APIs, so there is no sending IP to safelist, no SPF record to amend and no firewall exception to raise. Proofpoint’s own managed-service documentation says it will supply documents to safelist IP addresses for your email servers and that exceptions may need to be created in firewall or security appliances — the same mail-path work a change ticket usually has to carry.
Why pixel-based simulators produce false positivesA program that runs without a dedicated administrator
Proofpoint sells a separate paid tier — Applied Services for ZenGuide, and before it the commercial managed service capped at 2,500 users — specifically because campaign design, scheduling and execution are otherwise the customer’s job, and a Proofpoint expert only becomes the hands-on administrator under that add-on. Kinds Security assigns training and sends simulations without anyone building a campaign, at the base rate.
How the automation worksAn AI security advisor every employee can ask
Clay sits inside every workshop. Learners ask questions in plain language, by text or a live voice call, and get coached answers in their own language. It is the opposite end of the interaction from a report button: one collects what employees noticed, the other answers what they did not understand.
What Clay can see — and what your admins can’tThe audit artifact is in the base price
One click produces an audit-ready PDF per framework across 12 frameworks — HIPAA, SOC 2, PCI DSS, ISO 27001, CMMC, NIST CSF, GLBA/FTC Safeguards, FINRA, Texas DIR, LSC, safe-harbor and cyber-insurance attestation — scoped by date range and organization, each carrying a SHA-256 integrity hash so an assessor can confirm the file has not been edited.
What each framework actually requiresIn practice
One product, two names
Proofpoint’s awareness-training product is branded ZenGuide on its own site, having been sold for years as Proofpoint Security Awareness Training. Both names describe the same product, and third-party listings are split between them: some carry the historical review volume under the old name, while freshly created ZenGuide listings on Capterra and GetApp held no reviews at all when this page was written. Expect to see both names during an evaluation.
Where the simulation content comes from
This is the real dividing line. Proofpoint’s ThreatFlip workflow clones an actual malicious email your organization received, strips the payload and sensitive data, and turns it into a simulation — and the people the mail path shows are being targeted hardest can be enrolled into training automatically. Both capabilities are listed in Proofpoint’s own 2026 brief as benefits of integration with its Collaboration Security platform, which is a separate purchase. Kinds Security draws from a library of roughly 850 app-branded email templates instead. If your attack traffic already flows through Proofpoint, its pipeline is something no training-only vendor can reproduce.
What it takes to get the first simulation delivered
Proofpoint’s managed-service brief tells customers it will provide documents to safelist IP addresses for their email servers and to run spam-filter testing, and that exceptions may also need to be created in firewall or security appliances. That is the same mail-path preparation any SMTP-based simulator needs, and independent administrator knowledge bases still publish current Proofpoint allowlisting guides. Kinds Security sends through the Microsoft Graph and Gmail APIs, so the message is placed in the mailbox directly and there is nothing to allowlist. The trade is portability: SMTP-style delivery works in front of any mail provider, while API delivery depends on the mailbox connection.
Who is expected to run the program
ZenGuide gives an administrator a campaign builder — Adaptive Pathways and Adaptive User Grouping, driven by logic-based rules someone has to define. Proofpoint then sells a separate paid tier, Applied Services for ZenGuide, in which its own practitioners take over planning and execution; the earlier commercial managed brief states plainly that a Proofpoint expert will be the hands-on administrator, for organizations of up to 2,500 users. The existence of that tier is the clearest evidence of what the base product assumes. Kinds Security assumes the opposite: no administrator, no campaign builder, assignments that go out on their own.
Where the boundary between training and email security sits
Proofpoint’s email security is a much larger product line than its training product, and Kinds Security does not compete with it. A team that replaces ZenGuide with Kinds Security keeps whatever is filtering its mail; what it gives up is the pipeline between the two — training generated from its own attack traffic. That is a real cost for a Proofpoint email-security customer and no cost at all for anyone else, which is why this comparison turns on whether you already own the other half.
Deeper comparisons
Each dimension has its own fact-checked write-up with the underlying documentation.
Pricing
Kinds Security charges $1.50 per user per month, flat, with every feature included and no setup fee. Billing is monthly, there is no multi-year term and no user minimum is advertised. The trial is 21 days and self-serve.
Proofpoint publishes no pricing for ZenGuide anywhere on its site. Every product and platform page routes to “Request a demo” or “Contact Us”, and no self-serve trial-to-purchase path is described on any Proofpoint page. The product is also sold through the reseller channel — CDW and SHI both list Proofpoint Security Awareness Training SKUs for Standard and Enterprise tiers, banded by seat count — but those pages require a quote or an account login and display no list price to a visitor either.
Third-party software-aggregator sites publish estimated starting prices for Proofpoint. Those figures are not sourced to a Proofpoint price list, cannot be verified against a primary source, and are not reproduced here. This page states what Proofpoint publishes: nothing. If a number matters to your decision, the only way to get a real one is to request a quote — and the only honest comparison is between that quote and $1.50 per user per month.
When to choose each
Choose Kinds Security when
- You are buying security awareness training on its own, without also buying the vendor’s email security.
- You need a published price to budget against rather than a quote you have to request.
- Opening the mail path — safelisting sending IPs, amending SPF, raising firewall exceptions — is a change ticket you would rather not file.
- No one on the team is a full-time security awareness administrator, and paying a vendor to be one is not the answer you want.
- You need an audit-ready compliance report per framework without a separate line item.
Choose Proofpoint when
- You already run Proofpoint’s email security, and want simulations cloned from real attacks your workforce actually received.
- You want the people being targeted most — Proofpoint’s Very Attacked People — enrolled into training automatically off your own mail telemetry.
- You want one vendor across the mail path and the training program, on one contract.
- You want the program outsourced to the vendor and are willing to buy the Applied Services tier that provides it.
- You need a large catalogue of named regulatory topics to browse and assign against specific roles.
The question that decides it is narrow: does Proofpoint already sit on your mail path? If it does, the training product inherits data nothing else can. If it does not, ZenGuide is a quote-priced training platform that expects an administrator, and the comparison is much closer to even.
FAQ
Is Kinds Security better than Proofpoint?
Neither product is better in every case. Kinds Security is the stronger fit for teams buying awareness training on its own who want a published price, no allowlisting and no dedicated administrator. Proofpoint is the stronger fit for enterprises already running its email security, where simulations can be generated from attacks their own staff received.
What is the difference between Kinds Security and Proofpoint?
Kinds Security delivers email phishing simulations through the Microsoft Graph and Gmail APIs, assigns training without a campaign builder, and publishes a flat rate. Proofpoint’s ZenGuide is quote-priced, expects a customer-side administrator unless you buy its Applied Services tier, and draws its strongest content from an integration with Proofpoint’s separately sold email security.
Which is cheaper, Kinds Security or Proofpoint?
A like-for-like comparison is not possible from published information. Proofpoint publishes no price for ZenGuide anywhere on its site, and reseller listings require a quote or a login. Kinds Security publishes $1.50 per user per month, flat, with every feature included. Whether Proofpoint costs more or less depends entirely on the quote you are given.
Can Kinds Security replace Proofpoint?
It can replace Proofpoint’s awareness-training product, ZenGuide: email phishing simulation, automatic training assignment and audit-ready reporting across 12 compliance frameworks. It does not replace Proofpoint’s email security, which is a separate product line. Teams that move training off Proofpoint but keep it on the mail path give up the ThreatFlip and Very Attacked People pipeline.
Who should choose Proofpoint instead?
Choose Proofpoint if you already run its email security and want ZenGuide simulations cloned from real attacks your workforce received, with the most-targeted people enrolled automatically. It also suits enterprises that want one vendor across the mail path and training, or a paid managed tier in which Proofpoint administers the program.
Sources
- Proofpoint — ZenGuide solution brief (2026)The ZenGuide name, the AI ThreatFlip workflow, Very Attacked People auto-enrollment listed as a benefit of integration with Collaboration Security, Adaptive Pathways, and the Report Suspicious button.
- Proofpoint — Security Awareness Training product pageThe live product page, branded ZenGuide throughout, whose only calls to action are “Request a demo” and “Contact Us”. No pricing.
- Proofpoint — Enterprise Security Awareness Training briefReporting that identifies Very Attacked People and top clickers, with deeper attack-index and business-privilege insights marked “(with Proofpoint Threat Protection)”.
- Proofpoint — Managed Security Awareness Training, CommercialThe safelisting requirement for sending IP addresses and firewall exceptions, the “hands-on administrator” managed model, and the 2,500-user scope of the commercial managed tier.
- Proofpoint — Applied Services for ZenGuideThe current branding of the managed offering, in which Proofpoint practitioners handle program planning and execution.
- Proofpoint — Targeted Attack Protection guided trainingProofpoint describing the threat-data tie-in as an integration that takes its email security product’s data and ties it to the awareness-training product.
- Proofpoint — PhishAlarm email reportingThe one-click report button employees use to flag a suspicious message.
- Proofpoint — Multinational supportGlobal language support and WCAG-based accessibility, described without a current language count.
- Proofpoint — Security awareness training trust pageMulti-tenant AWS hosting across three regions, AES-256 and TLS, annual SOC 2 Type II, NIST 800-53 and ISO 27001 alignment, and the retention windows.
- Microsoft — Entra ID SSO for Proofpoint Security Awareness TrainingSAML single sign-on, service-provider and identity-provider initiated, with just-in-time provisioning.
- Okta — Proofpoint Security Awareness Training integrationThe SCIM provisioning scope: create, update, deactivate, group push and group linking.
- Kinds Security — PricingThe $1.50 per user per month rate, the 21-day trial and what the flat price includes.
Still deciding?
If you are buying awareness training on its own and would rather read a price than request one, the trial is 21 days and needs no demo call. If Proofpoint already filters your mail and you want simulations built from the attacks your own people received, Proofpoint is the honest answer and this page has said so.